comparison of wireless technologies

1. Bluetooth Wireless Technology

Bluetooth wireless technology is geared towards voice and data applications
Bluetooth wireless technology operates in the unlicensed 2.4 GHz spectrum
Bluetooth wireless technology can operate over a distance of 10 meters or 100 meters depending on the Bluetooth device class. The peak data rate with EDR is 3 Mbps
Bluetooth wireless technology is able to penetrate solid objects
Bluetooth technology is omni-directional and does not require line-of-sight positioning of connected devices
Security has always been and continues to be a priority in the development of the Bluetooth specification. The Bluetooth specification allows for three modes of security
The cost of Bluetooth chips is under $3

Ultra-Wideband (UWB)

UWB is a revolutionary wireless technology for transmitting digital data over a wide spectrum of frequency bands with very low power. It can transmit data at very high rates (for wireless local area network applications)
To date, UWB only has regulatory approval in the United States. UWB products are slow to come to market due to the disagreements over the standard and the lack of global regulatory approval
Ideally, it will have low power consumption, low price, high speed, use a wide swath of radio spectrum, carry signals through obstacles (doors, etc.) and apply to a wide range of applications (defense, industry, home, etc.)
Currently, there are two competing UWB standards. The UWB Forum is promoting one standard based on direct sequence (DS-UWB). The WiMedia Alliance is promoting another standard based on Multi-band Orthogonal Frequency Division Modulation (OFDM)
Each standard allows for data rates from approximately 0-500 Mbps at a range of 2 meters and a data rate of approximately 110 Mbps at a range of up to 10 meters
The Bluetooth SIG announced in May 2005 its intentions to work with both groups behind UWB to develop a high rate Bluetooth specification on the UWB radio

Certified Wireless USB

Speed: Wireless USB is projected to be 480 Mbps up to 2 meters and 110 Mbps for up to 10 meters. Wireless USB hub can host up to 127 wireless USB devices
Wireless USB will be based on and run over the UWB radio promoted by the WiMedia Alliance.
Allows point-to-point connectivity between devices and the Wireless USB hub
Intel established the Wireless USB Promoter Group in February 2004
The USB Implementers Forum, Inc. (USB-IF) tests and certifies the “certified Wireless USB” based wireless equipment

Wi-Fi (research 802.11)

Bluetooth technology costs a third of Wi-Fi to implement
Bluetooth technology uses a fifth of the power of Wi-Fi
The Wi-Fi Alliance tests and certifies 802.11 based wireless equipment
802.11a: This uses OFDM, operates in the 5 GHz range, and has a maximum data rate of 54 Mbps
802.11b: Operates in the 2.4 GHz range, has a maximum data rate of 11 Mbps and uses DSSS. 802.11b is the original Wi-Fi standard
802.11g: Operates in the 2.4 GHz range, uses OFDM and has a maximum data rate of 54 Mbps. This is backwards compatible with 802.11b
802.11e: This standard will improve quality of service
802.11h: This standard is a supplement to 802.11a in Europe and will provide spectrum and power control management. Under this standard, dynamic frequency selection (FS) and transmit power control (TPC) are added to the 802.11a specification
802.11i: This standard is for enhanced security. It includes the advanced encryption standard (AES). This standard is not completely backwards compatible and some users will have to upgrade their hardware. The full 802.11i support is also referred to as WPA2
802.11k: Under development, this amendment to the standard should allow for increased radio resource management on 802.11 networks
802.11n: This standard is expected to operate in the 5 GHz range and offer a maximum data rate of over 100 Mbps (though some proposals are seeking upwards of 500 Mbps). 802.11n will handle wireless multimedia applications better than the other 802.11 standards
802.11p: This standard will operate in the automotive-allocated 5.9 GHz spectrum. It will be the basis for the dedicated short range communications (DSRC) in North America. The DSRC will allow vehicle to vehicle and vehicle to roadside infrastructure communication
802.11r: This amendment to the standard will improve users’ ability to roam between access points or base stations. The task group developing this form in spring/summer 2004
802.11s: Under development, this amendment to the standard will allow for mesh networking on 802.11 networks. The task group developing this formed in spring/summer 2004
WiMAX (Worldwide Interoperability for Microwave Access and research 802.16)

WiMax is a wireless metropolitan area network (MAN) technology
WiMax has a range of 50 km with data rates of 70 Mbps. Typical cell has a shorter range
The original 802.16 standard operated in the 10-66 GHz frequency bands with line of sight environments
The newly completed 802.16a standard operates between 2 and 11 GHz and does not need line of sight
Delays in regulatory approval in Europe due to issues regarding the use of the spectrums in the 2.8 GHz and 3.4 GHz range
Supports vehicle mobility for between 20 to 100+ km/hr. The 802.16e standard will allow nomadic portability
The research 802.16a and the ETSI HIPERMAN (High Performance Radio Metropolitan Area Network) share the same PHY and MAC. 802.16 has been designed from the beginning to be compatible with the European standard
Created to compete with DSL and cable modem access, the technology is considered ideal for rural, hard to wire areas

WiBro (Wireless Broadband)

Portable Internet Service (WiBro) is to provide a high data rate wireless internet access with PSS (Personal Subscriber Station) under the stationary or mobile environment, anytime and anywhere. Primarily based in South Korea based on TTA specifications.
2300-2400 MHz, TDD, OFDMA, channel bandwidth 10 MHz, etc.
System shall support mobile users at a velocity of up to 60km/h
Throughput (per user) Max. DL / UL = 3 / 1 [Mbps], Min. DL / UL = 512 / 128 [Kbps]
Will come online Q1 2006

Infrared (IrDA)

IrDA is used to provide wireless connectivity for devices that would normally use cables to connect. IrDA is a point-to-point, narrow angle (30° cone), ad-hoc data transmission standard designed to operate over a distance of 0 to 1 meter and at speeds of 9600 bps to 16 Mbps
IrDA is not able to penetrate solid objects and has limited data exchange applications compared to other wireless technologies
IrDA is mainly used in payment systems, in remote control scenarios or when synchronizing two PDAs with each other

Radio Frequency Identification (RFID)

There are over 140 different ISO standards for RFID for a broad range of applications
With RFID, a passive or unpowered tag can be powered at a distance by a reader device. The receiver, which must be within a few feet, pulls information off the ‘tag,’ and then looks up more information from a database. Alternatively, some tags are self-powered, ‘active’ tags that can be read from a greater distance
RFID can operate in low frequency (less than 100 MHz), high frequency (more than 100 MHz), and UHF (868 to 954 MHz)
Uses include tracking inventory both in shipment and on retail shelves

Near Field Communication (NFC)

The NFC Forum is involved in the development and promotion of NFC. The 12 sponsor members of the NFC Forum include MasterCard International, Microsoft, Motorola, NEC, Nokia, Panasonic, Philips, Renesas, Samsung Electronics, Sony, Texas Instruments and Visa
Capacity: 212 kbps over a distance from 0 to 20 centimeters over the 13.56 Mhz frequency range
The NFC standard is based on RFID technology
Applications suggested for NFC include ticketing, payment and gaming.
Support for a passive mode of communication leads to savings on battery power

Near-Field Magnetic Communication

Proprietary wireless technology developed, patented and licensed by Aura Communications.
Range: 1.5 to 2 meters; Power: about 100 nanowatts; and frequency: 10 to 15 MHz. Creates a weak magnetic bubble of 4 to 6 feet in diameter in which it works
Currently this technology is only used for wireless headsets. An adapter must be attached to the phone since it is not integrated in any handset
Only available in the U.S. to-date


Speed: HiperLAN 2 = 54 Mbps, and has a 50 to 100 m capacity
No present killer application

Fixed wireless access standard developed by the European Telecommunications Standards Institute (ETSI)
Operates in the spectrum between 2 GHz and 11 GHz and is compatible/interoperable with the research 802.16a-2003 standard


Considered to be mobile wireless broadband wireless access.
Maximum data rate expected to be 1 Mbps, operating in licensed bands below 3.5 GHz
Supports vehicle mobility up to 250 km/hr

ZigBee (research 802.15.4)

The nine promoter companies of the ZigBee Alliance include Philips, Honeywell, Mitsubishi Electric, Motorola, Samsung, BM Group, Chipcon, Freescale and Ember; more than 70 members

Capacity of 250 Kbits at 2.4 GHz, 40 Kpbs at 915 Mhz, and 20 Kpbs at 868 Mhz with a range of 10-100 M
Its purpose is to become a wireless standard for remote control in the industrial field
The ZigBee technology is targeting the control applications industry, which does not require high data rates, but must have low power, low cost and ease of use (remote controls, home automation, etc.)
The specification was formally adopted in December 2004
Security was not considered in the initial development of the specification. Currently there are three levels of security
ZigBee and Bluetooth chips are both low cost.